Margaret Hodge is democracy so everyone should shut up and listen to her

The Guardian has reported that:

Treasury insiders have accused Margaret Hodge, the high-profile chairman of the parliamentary public accounts committee, of deterring multinational companies from coming to Britain.

A source said to be close to George Osborne briefed the BBC and Mail Online on Thursday about claims that senior ministers have been warned by businesses that the prospect of public humiliation in front of MPs and television cameras was making them think twice about where to invest. Hodge was singled out for particular criticism.

“Companies looking at Britain are being put off the idea of moving their headquarters here because they fear the level of public exposure for behaving perfectly legally. There is no doubt it is having an impact. We are trying to show we have one of the most competitive corporate tax regimes in the world, but the message is being sent out if you come here you will be exposed to this sort of criticism from Margaret Hodge and her committee,” the source said.

This is important. First, it shows the role of the Treasury in promoting the UK as a place which values the rule of law, something Hodge clearly opposes.

Second, it shows that the Treasury thinks that a committee whose job it is to examine Government budgets job should not be hauling in random businesses that are obeying the law as intended by Parliament (but not the Guardian, I should make clear; or Stemcor) in order to deliberately damage their reputations from behind the veil of Parliamentary Privilege.

Both actions are deeply subversive of democracy. Because if these matters were brought up in the House of Commons somebody might actually be able to reply to Margaret Hodge’s accusations of impropriety without her cutting them off.

And yes, in the interests of full disclosure I should make it clear that I do sometimes tell Margaret Hodge what she should say – because I am the voice of Civil Society


3 thoughts on “Margaret Hodge is democracy so everyone should shut up and listen to her

  1. Murphy

    It may interest you to know that someone USING A USERNAME OF MINE recently posted an outrageous comment in the comments section of the Guardian website for an article about Margaret Hodge scaring foreign tax dodging companies away from the UK. This comment suggested it was ironical that Hodge’s comments about tax avoiding companies and all the commentators who agreed with her were in fact posting on the website of a company which was part of a group that will avoid tax on £1bn on the sale of Autotrader in precisely the same way as some of the companies complained of by Hodge.

    I was most gratified to see that the comment was later removed by a moderator as breaching Guardian policy. Freedom of speech does not mean freedom to abuse and foment neo-liberal thinking.

    I will continue to regard the Manchester Guardian as the organ of choice for those who value freedom of speech, balance of views and the Civil Society. I know you agree with me.

  2. If only that nice Mrs Hodge had been the Judge at the Salem witch trails, surely more justice would have been handed out with many more people hung who were so obviously witches I wonder why they bothered having trials at all.

  3. Murphy, an important question for you, on a scale between your alter ego and 10, how lowly does Civil Society rate Ms Hodge?

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s